1960

• Raymond “Nig” Borleski
• Hiram Conibear
• Gretchen Kunigk-Fraser
• Helene Madison
• George Wilson

1961

• Herman Brix
• Gil Dobie
• Mel Hein
• Freddie Steele

1962

• Elgin Baylor
• Babe Hollingbery
• Freddie Hutchinson
• Jack Medica

1963

• Vean Gregg
• Ray Flaherty
• Hugh McElhenny
• Marvin “Bud” Ward
• Al Ulbrickson

1964

• Earl Averill
• Rusty Callow
• Bob Johnson
• Butch Meeker
• Arnold Reigger

1965

• Chuck Carroll
• Al Hostak
• Jack Nichols

1966

• Buck Bailey
• Clarence “Hec” Edmundson
• Olav Ulland

1967

• Morris “Red” Badgro
• Basil James
• Eddie O’Brien
• Johnny O’Brien

1968

• Gale Bishop
• Royal Brougham
• Turk Edwards

1969

• John Heinrick
• Bob Houbregs
• Harland Svare
• Earl Torgeson

1970

• Harry Deegan
• Harry Givan
• Jimmy Phelan
• Arnie Weinmeister

1971 – None

1972 – None

1973 – None

1974

• George Burns
• Tony Canadeo
• Jeff Heath
• Don Heinrich
• Leo Lassen
• Hal Lee

1975 – None

1976 – None

1977

• Sam Baker
• Harlond Clift
• Joe Gottstein
• Vic Markov
• Vince O’Keefe
• Gerry Staley
• Ernie Steele

1978

• Chuck Congdon
• Jack Friel
• Roy Johnson
• Bill Nollan
• Don Paul
• George “Rube” Walberg

1979

• Gene Conley
• Jack Fournier
• Bobby Galer
• Gerry Lindgren
• Bill Schumacher
• Ray Washburn

1980

• Keith Lincoln
• Brian Sternberg
• Joyner “JoJo” White
• Sammy White

1981 – None

1982 – None

1983

• Chuck Allen
• Enoch Bagshaw
• Ed Goddard
• Kaye Hall Greff
• Earl Johnson
• Bill Morris
• George Reed
• Ron Santo
• Jack Westland

1984 – None

1985 – None

1986

• Fred “Doc” Bohler
• Frank Foyston
• Bill Muncey
• Amos Rusie
• Paul Schwegler

1987 – None

1988 – None

1989

• Ed Brandt
• Gail Cogdill
• Woody Jensen
• Jim Owens
• Mel Stottlemyre
• Torchy Torrance
• Milt Woodard

1990 – None

1991 – None

1992 – None

1993 – None

1994

• Earl Anthony
• Hugh Campbell*
• Ron Cey
• Joanne Gunnerson-Carner
• Ray Frankowski
• Dick Hannula
• Marv Harshman
• Paul  Lindeman
• John McCallum
• Gordy Pfeifer
• Rick Redman
• Doug Smart
• Ken Still
• Wes Stock
• LaVern Torgeson*
• Jerry Williams*

1995 – None

1996

• Phil Mahre
• Steve Mahre
• Ahmad Rashad
• Stan Sayres
• Bob Schloredt

1997

• Fred Brown
• Jimmie Cain
• Tom Gorman
• Ray Mansfield
• Anne Quast Sander

1998

• Janet Hopps-Adkisson
• Don James
• Jack Sikma

1999

• Rod Belcher
• Rod Funseth
• Clay Huntington
• Steve Largent
• Pat Lesser-Harbottle
• Mac Wilkins

2000 – None

2001

• Bob Blackburn
• Les Keiter
• Georg Meyers
• Harry Missildine

2002 – None

2003

• Ira Flagstead
• Hub Kittle
• Ryne Sandberg

2004

• Frank Burgess
• Ben Cheney
• Steve Hawes
• Terry Metcalf
• Stan Naccarato
• Dave Niehaus

2005

• Mike Blowers
• John Chaplin
• Doris Severtson Brown Heritage
• Edo Vanni

2006

• Trish Bostrom
• John Cherberg
• Pat McMurtry

2007

• Vince Hanson
• Laurie Niemi
• Bob Robertson
• Frosty Westering

2008

• Guyle Fielder
• Pete Gross
• Mark Rypien
• Jack Sprenger
• Lenny Wilkens
• Jim Zorn

2009

• Michelle Akers
• William “Wee” Coyle 
• Jud Heathcote
• John Stockton

2010

• Edgar Martinez
• Dean Nicholson
• Emmett Watson
• Jim Whittaker
• Lou Whittaker

2011

• Chuck “Bobo” Brayton
• Don Coryell
• Bruce King
• John Olerud

2012

• Russell Baze
• Drew Bledsoe
• Cliff McCrath
• Warren Moon
• Ed Pepple
• Emil Sick

2013

• Ray Daughters
• Steve Emtman
• Bob Walsh

2014

• Alvin Davis
• Eddie Feigner
• Chip Hanauer
• Keith Jackson
• Gary Payton
• Detlef Schrempf
• Tom Sneva
• Jack Thompson

2015

• Chris Chandler
• James Edwards
• John Owen
• George Pocock
• Rosalynn Sumners
• Joyce Walker

2016 – None

2017

• Debbie Armstrong
• Byron Beck
• Dennis Erickson
• Mike Holmgren
• Kasey Keller
• Joe Steele
• Curt Warner
• Gary Wright